Not all backlinks are your friends… some are downright toxic.

Backlinks are like the friends who vouch for you at a party. They can boost your credibility and help you get noticed. But here’s the catch: not every friend is a good one. Toxic backlinks are the shady acquaintances of the SEO world, and instead of helping your site, they drag it down, sometimes all the way into Google’s bad books. 

The good news? You don’t have to keep them around. In this post, we’ll talk about what toxic backlinks are, why they’re bad news, and most importantly, how to remove toxic backlinks before they tank your SEO.

Meet Your Friends: What Are Backlinks, Really

Backlinks are like social shoutouts. They’re other sites pointing at you and saying, “This person’s cool, check them out!” When those shoutouts come from trustworthy, relevant sites, they help you climb the SEO ranks. But when they come from spammy, irrelevant, or downright shady places, you’ve got what we call toxic backlinks. And instead of boosting your rep, they’re like that one friend who always embarrasses you in public.

When Friends Turn Frenemies: Why Toxic Backlinks Hurt

So why should you care about these sketchy “friends”? Because toxic backlinks can drag your rankings down, make you look untrustworthy in Google’s eyes, and even earn you penalties. In other words, they’re not just dead weight, they’re actively working against you.

Think of it this way: if respected people vouch for you, your reputation grows. But if a bunch of shady characters start name-dropping you, people (and search engines) will assume you run in the same circles. Not a good look.

semrush backlink audit score example

Spotting the Shady Ones: How to Find Toxic Backlinks

Now comes the detective work. To check for toxic backlinks, you’ll need to dig into your backlink profile using tools like SEMrush’s Backlink Audit or Ahrefs’ Backlink Checker. These tools flag suspicious sites so you don’t have to comb through every single link manually.

Pro tip: Make “toxic backlink analysis” a regular habit. Kind of like unfollowing that weird old high school acquaintance who keeps posting conspiracy theories.

semrush backlink audit tool example

Red Flags That Scream ‘Toxic’

  • Links from irrelevant or spammy websites.
  • Exact-match anchor text stuffed unnaturally.
  • Links from obvious “link farms” or hacked sites.
  • Pages with zero real content – just ads or nonsense.

If any of your backlinks check these boxes, chances are they’re not your real friends.

Time for a Breakup: How to Remove Toxic Backlinks 

Once you’ve identified the culprits, it’s time to show them the door. Start by reaching out to the webmaster of the offending site and asking politely for removal. If that doesn’t work, don’t stress because you’ve got backup options.

Tools like SEMrush or Ahrefs let you track which links you’ve flagged and removed. And if all else fails, you can use Google’s disavow tool to tell search engines, “Hey, I don’t know these people. Please don’t count them against me.”

The Disavow Dilemm

Should I disavow toxic backlinks?” The short answer: only when you have to. If the links are clearly spammy and you can’t get rid of them any other way, yes. If not, save the nuclear option for truly toxic relationships. Think of it like blocking someone’s number – it’s effective, but you don’t do it lightly.

Choose Better Friends: How to Prevent Toxic Backlinks 

The best defense is a good offense. Keep creating high-quality content that earns natural, relevant backlinks from sites you actually want in your circle. Focus on building relationships, guest posting on reputable blogs, and making content people want to share.

When you surround yourself with solid, trustworthy “friends,” you’ll naturally crowd out the toxic ones.

Final Word: Keep Your Inner Circle Clean

Toxic backlinks might feel scary, but they’re manageable once you know how to spot and remove them. Think of it as spring-cleaning your SEO friend list: Out with the sketchy acquaintances, in with the real supporters.

Make a habit of running a toxic backlink check every so often, and you’ll keep your SEO reputation squeaky clean. Because at the end of the day, it’s not just about having backlinks, it’s about having the right ones.

  1.  
Want insights like this delivered right to your inbox? Sign up for our monthly newsletter, The Forge.